The Legal Examiner Affiliate Network The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner search feed instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content
| Shapiro, Appleton & Washburn

Last Wednesday, a Minnesota (MN) Washington County Court judge affirmed a $21.6 million jury verdict against rail operator Burlington Northern Santa Fe Corp. for failing to maintain a safe railroad crossing. The judge also assessed $4 million in penalties against BNSF for destroying evidence in the case and for paying unqualified individuals for supposedly expert testimony.

BNSF had been defending itself against civil charges that its neglect of crossing safety led to the deaths of 17-year-old Bridgette M. Shannon and of Brian L. Frazier, Harry J. Rhoades Jr. and Corey E. Chase in Anoka, Minnesota on the night of Sept. 26, 2003. Each of the young men were 20 years old when the car they and Shannon were in was struck by a freight train traveling through a crossing where gates to block cars and trucks was not working.

Citing court documents, a Star Tribune article listed the following actions as BSNF’s “biggest blunders” in presenting it unsupportable defense:

  • Destroying a laptop that contained data about the train’s speed and the crossing signal procedures.
  • Losing or destroying a computer disk containing train and signal performance information.
  • Failing to inform inspectors and plaintiffs that it knew of signal problems.
  • Destroying records of track work at the crossing.

Railroad crossings should to be clearly marked, and train operators must ensure that any installed crossing gates and warning bells and lights are maintained in proper working order. Also, while not required, it is advisable that active tracks have gates at crossings and that crossings be cleared of anything that can obstruct a driver’s, pedestrian’s or train engineer’s vision. Failure to meet to follow safeguards caused a collision between a freight train and a car as recently as this weekend.

The Toledo Blade reported Sunday morning that Chris Butler and his son his, Craig Chadwick, died when their car struck a Norfolk Southern freight train as it crossed a long, private gravel driveway in the town of Delta, Ohio. Neither Ohio nor federal laws requires trains to blow their whistles when they cross private roads or paths, and the crossing where Butler and Chadwick were killed is marked only with stop signs and “Private Railroad Crossing” signs. A large shrub blocks the view down the tracks in one direction.

Having represented victims of railroad accidents since the 1980s, I know too well how important clearly marking and safely maintaining railroad crossings are. Judgments such as those in the BNSF case go some way toward ensuring railroads keep crossings safe, but the tragic accident in Ohio should remind everyone that much progress remains to be made.

About the Editors: Shapiro, Cooper Lewis & Appleton is a law firm which focuses on injury and accident law, and we have experience handling FELA and general railroad injury cases. Check out our case results to see for yourself. Our primary office is in Virginia Beach, Virginia (VA). Our lawyers hold licenses in NC, SC, WV, KY and DC and have handled hundreds of railroad injury and FELA cases. We would like to send you one of our FREE reports about railroad injury and FELA cases, such as the Dos and Don’ts When Injured at a Railroad–The Railroad Workers FELA Rights and What Railroad Claim Agents Won’t Tell You (But You Must Know). We are ready to talk to you by phone right now. We provide free initial confidential injury case consultations, so call us toll free at 1-800-752-0042. Our injury attorneys also host an extensive injury law video library on Youtube. Further, our lawyers proudly edit the Virginia Beach Injuryboard and Norfolk Injuryboard as pro bono public information services.


Comments are closed.